Naïve straight boys Paulie Vauss and Brody Grant find themselves in a compromising position when they're tricked into shooting their first gay porn scene. Nervous but curious, they explore each other's bodies, tentatively stroking and sucking. Paulie's slender frame contrasts with Brody's athletic build, their erections tenting their boxers. They awkwardly sixty-nine, their inexperience making their pleasure all the more genuine. Analgayfetish captures their raw, unscripted journey as they learn the art of gay love.