Willy, the straight college jock with an ass too plump to ignore, finds himself the center of attention in a late-night dorm room dare. Surrounded by eager gay classmates, he hesitantly strips, revealing his untouched body and hard cock. The room erupts in appreciation as Willy tentatively strokes his length, his inexperience palpable. One by one, his friends drop their pants, their own cocks straining towards Willy. He freezes, then tentatively reaches out, touching another cock for the first time. The room is filled with the sound of wet flesh and eager moans as Willy explores his newfound desires, leading to a messy, unforgettable first time.