Damien, a lanky, blond-haired college freshman, is shocked to find his older brother Jeremy's hidden stash of gay porn. He can't help but watch, feeling his cock stir as he sees men sucking each other off and fucking. When Jeremy catches him, they have an uncomfortable conversation, but the tension between them is palpable. One night, after a few drinks, they find themselves making out, their hands exploring each other's bodies. Jeremy tentatively takes Damien's virginity, and from then on, they sneak touches and glances, testing their boundaries and exploring their newfound passion for each other, all while trying to keep it hidden from their conservative family and friends.