In a college dorm room, five straight-looking young men, all friends from their sports team, find themselves in an unexpected situation. A bet gone wrong leaves them stripping down, their cocks hardening as they realize they're now expected to perform gay acts on each other. Uncomfortable at first, they tentatively touch, lick, and suck, their initial hesitancy giving way to genuine pleasure. They discover the softness of another man's lips, the tightness of an ass, and the unique sensation of a tongue on their prostate. As they explore each other, they find that their straight labels no longer fit as snugly as they once did.