Two straight boys, Nathan and his buddy, are dared to give gay sex a try. They find themselves in a dimly lit room with an experienced gay top, his massive cock already hard and ready. Nathan's buddy chickens out, leaving Nathan to face the gay porn vet alone. The top lubes up Nathan's tight virgin hole, finger-fucking him gently before pushing his thick cock inside. Nathan gasps, his eyes wide, as he's filled for the first time by a man's cock, but he's determined to see it through, his straight boy pride on the line.