Nayely's eyes widen as El Papi Sayayin presents her with the list - 'anal' scrawled in bold letters. She's nervous but aroused, her pussy throbbing. El Papi lubes up her virgin asshole, pressing a finger inside, then another. Nayely moans, her body squirming. El Papi replaces his fingers with his cock, pushing past her tight rim. Nayely cries out, her nails digging into El Papi's back. He fucks her hard, his hips slapping against her ass, filling the room with the sound of their bodies colliding and Nayely's cries of pleasure mixed with pain.