Our eager amateur straight male, a tight-assed virgin at 25, embarks on his first anal journey. With trembling hands, he starts by tentatively probing his puckered hole with his fingers, moaning at the unexpected intensity of the sensations. He graduates to a series of hefty butt plugs, his eyes widening as each one pops past his sphincter, stretching his once-tight anus deliciously. The sight of his gaping, plugged hole in the mirror spurs him on, his cock throbbing at the sight of his newly loosened ass.