Petite 18-year-old Audrey Grace, caught masturbating by her stepbrother, is determined to prove she's straight. In a heated argument, she challenges him to fuck her roughly, asserting she won't enjoy it. Blindfolded, she's made to believe it's another girl, only to find her stepbrother's thick cock inside her. Audrey's tiny frame writhes as he pounds her, her initial resistance giving way to passionate moans, confirming her true desires.