Justin Magnum, the no-nonsense cop, encounters Nicole Aria, a cute petite shoplifter with a penchant for tight butt plugs. During her strip search, he discovers her secret and decides to give her a taste of her own medicine. He roughly handles her small tits and spanks her pert ass before bending her over and sliding his huge cock into her tight, untouched butt. Nicole gasps, her eyes wide with surprise and pleasure as Justin fills her ass, fucking her hard and deep, making her cum loudly. He pulls out, his cock glistening with her juices, and cums all over her back, leaving her breathless and taught a lesson she'll never forget.