In a moment of curiosity, Scott Finn wanders into his stepfather Jax Thirio's private study, where he stumbles upon a hidden cache of gay porn. The collection, filled with muscular men engaged in taboo acts like rimming and intense blowjobs, reveals a side of his stepfather he never knew existed. As Scott delves deeper, he finds videos featuring his stepfather himself, engaging in passionate gay sex with other men. The discovery leaves Scott reeling, struggling to reconcile the image of his stepfather with the reality of his secret life.