Under the mistletoe, Charlotte Sins initiates a naughty game of 'Never Have I Ever' with stepbrothers Rion King and Quinton James. As the drinks flow and inhibitions wane, the siblings confess their deepest desires. Charlotte admits she's never had both her brothers at once, Rion confesses he's never filled his sister's tight pussy, and Quinton reveals he's never tasted his sister's sweet nectar. Driven by lust and the spirit of giving, they decide to check off every item on their taboo Christmas list, their moans echoing through the house as they give each other the gift of their bodies.