Horny teen Maddy May thinks she can get away with shoplifting, but little does she know, the security camera has caught her red-handed. Store cop Mike Mancini confronts her, and instead of pressing charges, he offers her a different kind of punishment. He bends her over the counter, pulling down her pants to reveal her round, virgin ass. Maddy's eyes widen as she feels Mike's thick cock pressing against her tight pussy, but she's powerless to resist. He fucks her hard, filling the shop with her cries of pleasure and pain.