Ava Sinclaire and Alice Marie, two brainy babes, mastermind a catfish encounter, luring two unsuspecting studs, Stevie Moon and David Lee, into a raunchy foursome. The catfish begins innocently, but soon, tongues are wagging and lips are wrapped around thick, throbbing cocks. The nerds' reality check arrives as they swap spit and share the big dicks, moaning in pleasure while their catfish targets eagerly please them.