Elder Oliver Carter, tall and slender, finds his faith tested when Jonah Wheeler, a smooth, toned twink with a quiff, begins a series of teasing, submissive rituals. Jonah, in short hair and a suit, teases Oliver in his underwear, his small ass and shaved ass on full display. The ritual involves rimming, reverse-cowboy, and Oliver saying "yes, sir," which conflicts with his Mormon upbringing. Oliver starts having serious doubts about his faith, as Jonah's tease becomes harder to resist.