April Olsen and Cierra Bell, two stepsisters with a penchant for petty crime, get caught shoplifting by security guard Marcus London. Instead of calling the police, he propositions them with a salacious offer: a threesome in exchange for his silence. The young, small-breasted teens, eager to avoid trouble, agree. They start by taking turns sucking Marcus's cock, their tight, inexperienced mouths struggling to accommodate his size. Then, they take him in every position imaginable - doggystyle, cowgirl, missionary - their wet, virgin pussies stretching to accommodate his thick shaft.