In the dimly lit confessional, Father Nicholas Ryder, a young, innocent-looking priest, hears the whispered tales of a wayward parishioner. Puka Shell Dude, the twinkish penitent, shares his gay fantasies, his voice thick with desire. Father Nicholas, though shocked, feels an unholy stir within. As the confessions grow more explicit, so does his arousal, his thick, big dick straining against his priestly robes. Unable to resist, he offers Puka Shell Dude a unique form of penance - a bareback, holy fuck in the church's sacristy.